Plans for Flamingoland, the controversial tourist development at Balloch on the banks of Loch Lomond, have been rejected by the Scottish Government.
But, like a bad smell, the applicant whose proposal was opposed by 155,000 people, has decided to hang around for more litigation and reports, just as it has done for past ten years, costing £millions of public money.
They have made it plain that they will not take No for an answer.
Lomond Banks – which is owned by the theme park operator Flamingo Land – had sought permission to build two hotels, a water park, and more than 100 lodges at the site near Balloch.
The plans resulted in widespread public backlash, with more than 150,000 people signing a Scottish Greens-organised petition against the resort.
After a revised set of proposals were rejected by the Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park authority in September 2024, a Scottish Government Reporter overturned the verdict on appeal.
However, Scottish Ministers reversed that decision today (Tuesday), disagreeing with the government’s previous conclusions that the development would create a conflict with Scotland’s National Park Aims.
A report says that the rejection was “a finely balanced decision” and concedes that allowing the resort reap economic benefits for the area.
They added: “When taken together with the other development plan conflicts identified, the proposed development does not comply with the development plan overall”.
The formal decision from the SNP Minister Ivan McKee, right, reads: “The material considerations do not outweigh the identified policy conflicts with the development plan in this instance.
“Accordingly, for the reasons given above, the Scottish Ministers hereby dismiss the appeal and refuse planning permission in principle for the proposed development.”
Taking to X to celebrate the dismissal, Scottish Greens co-leader Ross Greer, pictured left, wrote: “Flamingo Land has finally been rejected!
“For the last decade we have fought to save Loch Lomond from this destructive mega-resort plan.
“Thank you to the 155,000 people who joined our movement. This is your victory.”
Greer had been critical of the government’s stance on Flamingo Land, telling The [Glasgow] Herald last summer that they had made “deeply questionable decisions”.
A Scottish Government spokesperson previously said: “Ministers decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park.”
Heather [The Weather] Reid, pictured right, convener of Loch Lomond & The Trossachs National Park Authority, said: “In September 2024, our Board voted unanimously to refuse the Lomond Banks planning application.
Today, Scottish Ministers confirmed their decision to dismiss the appeal against that decision. This means the National Park Authority’s refusal of planning permission in principle stands.
“We very much welcome this decision, which largely vindicates and aligns with key conclusions reached by both our Planning Officers’ recommendation and our Board in its unanimous refusal of this application.
“It also provides welcome clarity as to how National Planning Framework 4 policies on flooding, woodland protection and biodiversity should be applied.
“This is a successful outcome that recognises the statutory aims of the National Park and supports the long-term vision for the National Park set out in our National Park Partnership Plan – a vision where people and nature not only coexist, but thrive together.
“Our Planning Officers will now review the Ministers’ decision in full and consider all accompanying report details.
“There remains a six-week period during which the applicant or a third party may seek a legal challenge to the decision.
“Meanwhile, our long-term commitment to working with the local community in Balloch continues, ensuring their voices and priorities help shape future land use, including through the current preparation of its Local Place Plan and the Balloch Pierhead Improvement Action Plan.”
Commenting on news that the Flamingo Land planning application has been rejected, Scottish Labour 
MSP Jackie Baillie, left, said “I welcome this decision. It has long been clear that the proposal was flawed and it was rejected by the overwhelming majority of my local community.
“It beggars belief that just months ago, the Scottish Government initially refused to call the application in for scrutiny and their own Planning Reporter gave this decision the go-ahead.
“The Scottish Government has finally taken the right decision, which goes to show that there is nothing like an election to concentrate minds.
“I am absolutely delighted at this outcome. Loch Lomond is a very special place and, with Balloch as its gateway, we need to be careful to have the right development for the area.”
Jim Paterson, the development director for Lomond Banks, said it was “extremely disappointed” by the decision, adding the plans “represented a transformational investment in Balloch and the wider area, delivering significant employment, regeneration and long-term economic benefits to one of Scotland’s most disadvantaged communities”.
Mr Paterson said: “The independent reporter appointed by the Scottish Government carefully assessed the application and was still minded to recommend approval, recognising the substantial socio-economic, tourism and heritage benefits the project would bring.
“Today’s outcome is dismissive of the reporter’s recommendation and flies in the face of what this area was ear-marked to accomplish, which is bad news for Scottish business and tourism as a whole, not to mention the local people who will now miss out on jobs, local supply chain opportunities and wider investment as a result.”
He added: “We note that the ministers’ reasons for refusal relate primarily to flood risk modelling and ancient woodland impacts.
“We remain confident that these matters can be fully addressed through detailed design, further technical assessment and appropriate mitigation, as is standard practice at the planning permission in principle stage.
“We will now carefully review the decision in full and consider our options.”
INFORMATION: The Dumbarton Democrat has today at 2.30pm reached 5,000 views and visitors. We expect that number to continue to increase over the next few hours and days despite efforts by intruders to break into our site and post fake stories and pictures, which we have now had taken down. We will continue to provide the truth in the news for our readers and defy these attempts to gag us. We know West Dunbartonshire Council for one does not like that we speak truth to power, but that is our job, that is our mission and we intend to stick with it. Bill Heaney, Editor/Owner, The Dumbarton Democrat
Correct decision by the Scottish Government and a huge victory for people power and local democracy. Balloch & Haldane Community Council and Ross Greer of the Green Party deserve enormous credit for backing local people’s opposition to Flamingo Land.
Speaking truth to power is behind this decision and it shows when people unite to fight the market and big business, victories can be won.