She had spoken with members of the health board, staff, trade unions, patients and the public about what had been going on.
Ms Constance said: “I reiterate my commitment to transparency. By the end of November, I will write to the Health, Care and Sport Committee, setting out a detailed timeline of the Government’s activity and correspondence with NHS Grampian over the past year, alongside the milestones that I expect to be demonstrated.”
In other words, she wants to see significant change for the better by Christmas.
Although there were some clear failures within the past year, many of the issues were long-standing and systemic.
“The chief executive has held up her hands and apologised where she has made mistakes, and she has shown a commitment to dismantling the poor organisational culture that led to many of the issues.
“Importantly, both the chief executive and the interim chair know that they have until the end of the year to provide evidence of urgent improvements. The board requires stability to do that.”
She added: “I have been asked what role the Government has played. Healthcare Improvement Scotland operates independently of the Government and is responsible for monitoring the quality of care that is provided across our NHS.
“HIS raises issues directly with health boards and with the Government. When it does, I am clear that the learning should always be applied across our entire NHS.”
Which means that the changes that are recommended by HIS will need to be implemented across the Greater Glasgow and Clyde Health Board, which covers West Dunbartonshire and has had to face widespread criticism and condemnation for its performance since the much maligned Queen Elizabeth University Hospital officially opened.
Ms Constance said that her predecessor chaired the board’s annual review in October 2025. At that point, it was stated by NHS Grampian that clear progress was being made in making improvements, including for significant adverse event reviews.
She added: “That raises serious questions about the accuracy of the information that was being scrutinised by the board and shared with the Government.
“The HIS review notes that, although surgeons were instructed in late June 2026 to cease paediatric surgery at Dr Gray’s, that instruction was not implemented until August. That is an extremely serious and wholly unacceptable failure.
“When I became aware of the paediatric service cessation in August, through media interest, I acted immediately by speaking to the chief executive, setting clear expectations for safe and rapid restoration, and visiting Dr Gray’s within days to meet the chief executive and staff.
“In August, the board chair announced that she was stepping down. The Government took steps to appoint a new interim chair of the board, John Connaghan CBE, who started in October. John has my utmost confidence because he has a clear track record of delivery within the NHS. As the report highlights, information was not being openly or properly shared or escalated to or by the board, so change must happen now.”
What is evidenced in this report is that the status quo is not working due to a failure of leadership, governance and accountability, the Health Secretary said.
She added: “Finally, and of significant concern to me, there are the issues in relation to organisational culture. I find it completely intolerable that the review found a culture of “us” and “them”. That will not be tolerated going forward, and I have written to the staff side and trade unions to make clear that staff who raise concerns have a right to be heard without fear of detriment.
“I have also written to Scotland’s independent national whistleblowing officer to invite them to engage with NHS Grampian’s work. There can be no lasting improvement in patient safety, organisational culture or public confidence unless staff are confident that their voices are heard and their concerns addressed.
“The evidence is clear that the principal challenge lies not with front-line staff but with leadership. I welcome that NHS Grampian has established a dedicated helpline for patients and their families. Patients must continue to access their local services. They are safe, and that is evidenced by the HIS reports on the professionalism of staff who are delivering services directly on the ground.”
She told MSPs: “The inspection was in April this year, and red flags were raised with the Scottish Government’s deputy chief medical officer in May this year.”
And she asked: “Why were ministers not alerted to the issue in May, given the substantial safety issues at stake?
“Why did the cabinet secretary say to the press that she found out only a few weeks ago when, in her statement, she said that she visited in August because of her concerns?
“Was the previous cabinet secretary told? Is it not beyond belief that those who should be held accountable have all mysteriously left their posts?
“We know that there was at least one serious adverse event review when a patient died in theatre. Will the cabinet secretary instruct a thorough review of all patient cases since the safety issues were first identified, about which there are potential concerns?”
Angela Constance replied: “I am grateful to Ms Baillie for her scrutiny on this serious matter. I, for one, do not demur from one word in the Healthcare Improvement Scotland diagnostic review, as it is a substantial and thorough piece of work.
“I am committed to transparency and will outline the Government’s engagement on the issue over the past year. I will do that to the Health, Care and Sport Committee, as it is important.
“However, as the HIS report says, we need to move beyond describing the problems and get on with the action, and that is the focus right now.
On Ms Baillie’s question on serious adverse event reviews, she will recall from the briefing yesterday that the interim chair said that he was prepared to change the priority that is given to any individual adverse event review. I will make sure that her comments are passed to the interim chair and the board and given all due consideration.”
Top of page picture: Health Secretary Angela Constance

