Site icon THE DEMOCRAT

National Health Service scandal leads to £100 MILLION compensation claim

Pressure is growing on the SNP government over the crisis after it emerged Humza Yousaf took no action when concerns were raised four years ago

First Minister John Swinney faces the media after FMQs on Thursday when he was quizzed on the crisis at NHS Grampian

Pressure is growing on John Swinney over the crisis at NHS Grampian, with the First Minister being told to publish all correspondence between his government and the health board.

Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has written to the SNP, saying serious questions remain unanswered about the scandal.

It comes after Police Scotland launched a probe into claims that 19 patients died needlessly at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib – a surgeon at ARI – spoke to journalists on Thursday after saying he had attempted to contact the Scottish Government on four occasions since 2022, as well as speaking to police, about patient care.
Mr Swinney was accused of hiding behind civil servants on Thursday when he said he had not been made aware of the letters sent by Dr Habib until they were made public on Thursday.
It has since emerged that a bombshell dossier was passed on to Humza Yousaf when he was health minister in 2022, and he discussed it with Chief Medical Officer Sir Gregor Smith.

The review, instructed by NHS Grampian in September 2022, looked at 45 liver and pancreatic surgery cases and found there were 19 avoidable deaths among the 31 who died between 2015 and 2021.

However, the pair took no further action. It has now been claimed Ministers and health chiefs could face compensation claims from families, with the potential bill reaching over £100 million.

Mr Findlay challenged Mr Swinney on the issues at FMQs yesterday and has followed that up with a letter asking key questions about the scandal.

This includes calling on him to publish all “correspondence between your government and NHS Grampian regarding governance issues and patient safety within the health board”.

The Tory chief also calls for the government to “urgently order NHS Grampian to ensure that no documents relating to these matters are destroyed,” and asks why the Nats ‘suppressed’ the 2022 review.

It calls on bereaved families to be “fully informed of the circumstances of their deaths,” and asks why no action was taken against senior NHS Grampian executives and “why were they allowed to take up lucrative posts with other Scottish NHS boards”.

Scottish Conservative leader,
Russell Findlay 

Finally, the letter calls for the First Minister to “order the Independent National Whistleblowing Officer to do its job of listening to all whistleblowers rather than putting up barriers to them”.

Mr Findlay told the SNP leader: “It is evident that NHS Grampian failed to respond to serious and sustained concerns about these avoidable patient deaths and embarked on covering them up.

“Not only did your government fail to act but also engaged in the cover up. This represents a sickening, and potentially criminal, betrayal of innocent patients and their families.

“This scandal is entirely consistent with a toxic culture nurtured by your party during its two decades of running our great country. This culture can be characterised as dishonest, self-serving and contrary to the interests of the people of Scotland.

“The disgusting cover-up that ensued risks destroying the trust of the paying public and does a gross disservice to the vast majority of heroic NHS staff who work tirelessly to deliver effective and compassionate care.”

Dr Habib’s evidence came just a week after the publication of a damning report about the health board by Healthcare Improvement Scotland. It found “serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across the acute sector of NHS Grampian”.

She accused Health Secretary Angela Constance of “dither and delay, while families are without the transparency they need” and said there had been a “monumental failure of governance, with devastating consequences”.

She added: “The facts are that 19 people in the care of our NHS died when they should not have been. We now know that serious concerns were being raised about avoidable deaths, with a paper trail showing correspondence with Scottish Government officials and Police Scotland.

“Despite this, no action was taken, Aberdeen Royal Infirmary continued to operate as normal, and patients were left in the dark.”

In an interview on BBC Radio Scotland’s Breakfast programme this morning, Friday, Ms Constance said she considered ARI to be “safe” despite the damning evidence.

She added: “I want immediate action and improvements, but it also has to be sustained for the longer term, and that is why additional people on the ground have been put in place in NHS Grampian to support the new chair, to support the new people that will be coming into the board, to support those that are newly appointed to a range of positions in terms of clinical governance, because there must be that oversight, that scrutiny, as well as the support.”

The health board could also face potential legal action from the families of those who have been impacted. Trish McFadden, a partner at Digby Brown, said it had been working with impacted families before Thursday’s revelations and more have since been in contact.

“The families that I am acting on behalf of want answers, they want transparency,” she said.

“They want to know why things happened the way they did and to effect change for the future.”

Thompsons Solicitors claimed individual payouts could reach as high as £10 million, with the total bill more than £100 million, though Ms McFadden was reticent to say how much the cases could cost the public purse.

In a statement on Thursday, NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said: “We are aware of the serious allegations raised today. A thorough investigation has already taken place into these matters, with some elements of that work ongoing.

Solicitor Ammer Anwar pictured with his client, whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib as police probe deaths at ‘slaughterhouse’ Aberdeen hospital

“It is important we respect patient and employee confidentiality, but we can highlight that where reviews identify issues around patient care, the appropriate duty of candour processes are followed. This includes direct communication with patients and families where required. If our consideration of any new evidence identifies further individuals who should be contacted, we will do so. Patient safety remains our highest priority.”

Angela Constance shamed as damning report reveals health board put children in danger.

Top of page: First Minister John Swinney in the Scottish Parliament with Health Secretary Angela Constance and Education Secretary Mairi McAllan.

Exit mobile version