Covid: Patients still being sent to care homes without negative tests

Care homes in Dumbarton which were caught up in the Covid-19 tragedy. 

By Democrat reporter

Opposition parties are demanding that the SNP Government place a complete ban on discharging patients to care homes without two negative tests for Covid-19.

The two test policy was introduced in April, but the health secretary has confirmed such discharges are still allowed.

Jeane Freeman, pictured right,  said it was “right and proper” that clinicians had the final say in exceptional cases.

The Scottish Conservatives, Labour and the Lib Dems have called for the practice to be stopped.

  • What went wrong in Scotland’s care homes?
  • Scottish care home deaths overtake hospital deaths

Large numbers of elderly patients were moved out of hospital in the early weeks of the pandemic amid fears the NHS could soon become overwhelmed.

However, an analysis by Public Health Scotland published last month found no “statistically significant evidence” that it caused the high rate of infection and deaths in care homes.

The policy of hospital patients having two negative tests prior to discharge to a care home was introduced on 21 April.

The report, however, noted “there are valid clinical reasons for individuals not to be tested prior to discharge, relating to their capacity to consent to testing and avoiding causing distress, and to appropriateness of testing, e.g. in end of life care situations”.

In a response to a parliamentary question from Labour’s Monica Lennon, reported in the Sunday Mail, Ms Freeman confirmed patients could still be discharged to care homes without a second negative test if it was in their “clinical interests”.

“This clinically led decision is for exceptional circumstances and after a full risk assessment, consulting the resident, family and care home on what is right for the individual and putting appropriate mitigating actions and support in place,” she said.

Pressed on the issue on the BBC’s Sunday Politics, Ms Freeman said: “It is entirely right and proper, I think, that clinicians who are experienced in elderly care and medical care and social work staff experienced in social work support for older people are the ones who will make the final decision.”

Opposition MSPs are calling for the practice to be stopped immediately.

Monica Lennon, pictured left, Scottish Labour’s health spokeswoman, said: “People known to have Covid-19 should not be placed in care homes and Jeane Freeman must put a stop to this dangerous practice immediately before more lives are lost.

“Thousands of older and disabled people living in care homes have been forbidden from even talking to their loved one through the window, yet the Scottish government is allowing residents to bring the virus through the back door.

“Too many lives have already been sacrificed. This must end today.

Opposition parties have called for a more detailed inquiry into hospital discharges to care homes.

Scottish Conservative health spokesman, Donald Cameron said: “The SNP have clearly not learned the harsh lessons of the first wave of the pandemic, when we saw Covid-19 ripping through care homes if given even the slightest chance.

“This isn’t about challenging clinical decisions, it’s about the reckless message being sent from the health secretary that it could be ‘entirely right and proper’ to discharge patients without a test.”

Scottish Lib Dem spokesman Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP said: “What is happening is the opposite of what we were told by the government.

“There is now categoric proof that the double test protection policy is not being followed.

“The buck has to stop with ministers who have been all over the place on this.

“Care home residents and their families deserve to be treated better.”

Linda Bauld, pictured right, professor of Public Health at Edinburgh University, said that testing on discharge from hospital was a really important component of protecting care homes and something “we didn’t get right” in the first wave of the pandemic.

She said: “I know it is down to clinical judgement but ideally all these patients should be tested and they should be tested twice.”

Asked if there would be cases where that was not appropriate, she said: “There would really need to be exceptional circumstances for that to be justified.”

Leave a Reply