PARLIAMENT: Never-ending Covid ID requirements are ‘a dog’s breakfast’

By Bill Heaney

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton has today warned that unless the Scottish Government ditch their controversial Covid ID scheme they risk discriminating against young, poor and ethnic minority Scots and driving night time businesses to the wall.

Today the Scottish Government published more information about their Vaccine Certification proposals including confirmation that the scheme will apply from Friday 1 October (from 5 am) “until further notice”, and Ministers will hold the power to extend the regulations on a three-weekly basis.

However, there is still no sign of the relevant regulations or impact assessments, and additional staffing or infrastructure costs will be met by businesses. 

Earlier in the day, Judith Robertson, chairwoman of the Scottish Human Rights Commission told the Scottish Parliament’s Covid committee:

“From our perspective, that case [for Covid ID cards] has not been made at the moment, or if it has it’s not in the public domain… That is one of the key aspects in relation to those human rights considerations, that the evidence upon which decisions are being made be placed into the public domain so that not only the basis on which decisions are being made is clear but that can be interrogated by a wider element of the population. There isn’t a clarity around what evidence has been used to base the decisions on.” 

Mr Cole-Hamilton said: “The Scottish Government are expecting pubs and clubs to deal with complex and never-ending restrictions, while demanding they pick up the tab for it too. Good businesses will go to the wall because the government simply hasn’t thought this through.

“Today we have heard from human rights experts that there is no clarity about what evidence has been used to make these decisions, and discovered that these restrictions will be extended and imposed by ministers in dark rooms without Parliament or the public getting a say. That’s a dark route for Scotland to start down.

“Unless these proposals are ditched in the next seven days, young people, poor people and ethnic minority Scots will wake up to find themselves second class citizens.”

Responding to UK Hospitality Scotland Executive Director Leon Thompson’s comments on Good Morning Scotland, when he said – “We are seven days from this coming in, we haven’t seen the regulations that the government are still drafting, we haven’t seen any guidance from the Scottish Government and the government hasn’t produced any business impact assessment or indeed a quality impact assessment either, so we are really still very much in the dark”.

Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton said:  “The hospitality industry thinks this scheme is a dog’s breakfast. They are being expected to get hold of new equipment in a week, without even getting clear guidance of what is expected of them. 

“The First Minister has provided no clarity about how she expects venues to spotcheck their patrons nor how “visual checks” of QR codes work. Unless a bouncer possesses Robocop-like skills, that will not be possible.

“The Government is risking pushing people into a Covid ID black market and making premises less safe for everyone.

“We are only seven days away from the introduction of this scheme but businesses and patrons are still in the dark.”


Congratulations! Your website, THE DUMBARTON DEMOCRAT, passed 500,000 all-time views.


Leave a Reply