Shona Robison announced the income tax changes as she unveiled the Scottish budget.
If you are already earning between £75,000 and £125,000 then you will hardly have noticed the Cost of Living crisis.
The Budget news today that higher earners in Scotland are to pay more income tax won’t have you looking for the address of your nearest food bank.
A new 45% band will be introduced for people earning between £75,000 and £125,140 – meaning they will pay more tax than they currently do.
The top rate of tax, paid by those earning more than £125,000, will also rise from 47% to 48%.
And the current threshold for paying the higher band – £43,663 – will be frozen instead of rising by inflation.
So, the people in the middle, who are forever being squeezed when it comes to taxation of every kind, including council tax – and so much else – were given a break today by Finance Secretary Shona Robison.
Her budget was something of a non event, a let down for the majority of the electorate who had expected more, when she unveiled the government’s budget for next year.
It included funding increases for the health service and councils – the latter to help offset a freeze in council tax – but cuts to enterprise funding, housing and rural affairs.
The tax changes mean Scotland will have six income tax bands while the rest of the UK has three, with middle and higher earners in Scotland paying more than other parts of the country.
The Scottish government estimates that 114,000 people will pay the new advanced tax rate for those earning between £75,000 and £125,000, with a further 40,000 people paying the top rate for those earning more than £125,000.
The announcement is designed to help plug a £1.5bn funding shortfall in the Scottish budget, with Ms Robison saying the tax rises for higher earners would raise an additional £80m.
The finance secretary also confirmed the current thresholds for the higher and top bands – £43,663 and £125,140 respectively – would be frozen, while the basic and intermediate bands will see the rates at which they kick in rise by the rate of inflation.
The freezing of the thresholds means more people 9in the middle, of course0 will find themselves being pulled into a higher tax band after being given pay rises which will be negated by that move.
The Scottish Fiscal Commission (SFC), forecasts that the tax changes will bring in a total of £1.5bn in revenue funding next year alone, although its chairperson said “tough decisions” were still likely to be necessary in individual government departments.
People who earn more than £28,850 in Scotland – slightly above median earnings – already pay more income tax than they would elsewhere in the UK, with those earning less than that amount paying slightly less.
The changes mean that anyone earning £50,000 in Scotland will pay £1,542 a year more than they would if they lived in another part of the UK, while people earning £150,000 will pay £6,000 more, according to the Scottish Fiscal Commission.
Ms Robison told MSPs the Scottish government would provide local authorities with £140m in additional funding to help finance a council tax freeze.
For local councils such as West Dunbartonshire that is a drop in the ocean, although it’s more than enough for them now to save face and, in light of the budget, they will be able to keep Balloch Library open as a community hub for one of the most deprived areas in this part of the country.
Council umbrella body Cosla had called for £300m to cover the freeze, which was announced by First Minister Humza Yousaf in October, with a report published last week warning that it was “only a matter of time” before a council effectively went bankrupt.
Bankruptcy was what the Labour administration’s Cllr David McBride said West Dunbartonshire Council would be facing if they gave in to the plea from the children, parents and grandparents who petitioned them and protested against the library closure.
Balloch Library protest – will new money cause the Council to think again about closure?
That was no more than a piece of shroud waving by a politician with his back to the wall.
Other major announcements from the national budget included the government’s intention to increase the Scottish Child Payment from £25 to £26.70 from April of next year.
Campaigners had called for an increase to £30 a week and Child Poverty Action Group director John Dickie called the budget announcement “bitterly disappointing”.
Ms Robison also said the government would provide £1.5m to local authorities to cancel school meal debt.
According to research by the Aberlour children’s charity published in October, more than 30,000 children had debts worth a total of £1.8m – up by 60% on the previous year.
Funding for NHS boards such as Greater Glasgow, which covers West Dunbartonshire, will rise “above real terms” by £550m (4.3%) MSPs were told, but that is hardly like to shorten the record breaking queues of people waiting for treatment in our hospitals.
The deputy first minister also announced business rates for premises valued at less than £51,000 will be frozen, while hospitality businesses in Scotland’s islands will be given 100% relief, capped at £110,000 per firm.
That does nothing for mainland businesses such as the tourism industry on Loch Lomondside and Argyll and Bute who will be forced to pay the same costs despite the fact that their income has dropped off considerably in the wake of the Covid pandemic.
The small business bonus scheme will also continue while the government will assess how valuations for business rates are carried out, Ms Robison said.
The finance secretary said Holyrood’s block grant funding, derived from UK government spending decisions, had fallen by 1.2% in real terms since 2022-23.
The SNP were once again engaging in the blame game when Shona Robison stated: “Devolution has brought many benefits, but it has also exposed quite how beholden we are to the decisions of Westminster.. We are fighting Westminster austerity with one hand tied behind our back.”
Prime Minister Rishi Sunak said ahead of the budget announcement that the UK government was providing a record amount of funding via the Barnett formula to Scotland.
Speaking during a visit north of the border on Tuesday, he said Scotland was the highest taxed part of the UK and that it would be “very disappointing” to see tax rates rise further.
The Finance secretary says she’s making very different choices to the UK government.
In broad terms by increasing the tax take and not replicating the business tax cuts introduced by the UK government, the Scottish government has created a pot of money to spend on public services.
There’s extra cash for the health service and for social security benefits, and real terms increases in the education and justice budgets.
But the wellbeing economy, rural affairs and housing budgets have been cut.
Opposition politicians argue that had the SNP not wasted millions on failed projects it would have even more money to spend
Scottish Tory finance spokeswoman Liz Smith criticised the “extraordinary late delivery” of the budget to oppositions MSPs, who were given only a few minutes to examine the document before the announcement. She called it “discourtesy to parliament”.
She accused the government of a “complete abrogation of responsibility for the running of the Scottish economy” since the SNP came to power in 2007.
Ms Smith questioned whether the government was sending out “the right message that Scotland is open for business”.
She said: “For economic growth, for investment, innovation and job creation?”
“Because it’s abundantly clear that business and industry doesn’t think so.”
Ms Robison apologised to MSPs for the late delivery of the budget.
Scottish Labour finance spokesman Michael Marra claimed it was a “chaotic” budget from an “incompetent government that will leave ordinary Scots paying much more and getting much less in return”.