Starmer breaks silence over Mandelson sacking: ‘Had I known what I know now, I’d have never appointed him’
By Lucy Ashton
Sir Keir Starmer has attempted to move on from Peter Mandelson’s Epstein scandal hours ahead of US President Donald Trump’s state visit to London today (Tuesday).
It looks now as if even all the King’s horses and the UK government’s spin doctors have little chance of saving the Prime Minister’s skin and that 10 Downing Street will be seeking a new occupier come next summer.
As he sought to get back on the front foot after his “phase two” plan for government got off to a chaotic start, the prime minister attempted to move on from the fiasco hours before Donald Trump’s historic second state visit.
But even as he tried to bolster his position, he was rocked by yet another resignation when key aide Paul Ovenden quit as head of strategy in a fresh scandal over obscene emails about veteran MP Diane Abbott. The dramatic developments came as:
- Nigel Farage pressed home his poll advantage by unveiling the first defection of a sitting MP to Reform
- Questions were raised about when Lord Mandelson’s dynamite Epstein emails landed on the PM’s desk
- Labour MPs publicly and privately suggested Sir Keir could be out in months, with one minister calling him “screwed”

Meanwhile, two of Britain’s leading pollsters warned Labour is facing even worse problems with voters, with one suggesting the party “is yet to hit rock bottom”.
With the crisis over Lord Mandelson throwing serious questions on his judgement as prime minister, Sir Keir held a morning meeting with his junior ministers in Downing Street to “rally the troops”.
He insisted he would have “never appointed” Lord Mandelson “had I known then what I know now”, in his first comments since sacking him over links to Jeffrey Epstein.
He said the “nature and extent of the relationship” between the convicted paedophile and Lord Mandelson is “far different to what I’d understood to be the position at the point of appointment”.

“But had I known then what I know now, I’d have never appointed him, because what emerged last week were emails, Bloomberg emails which showed that the nature and extent of the relationship that Peter Mandelson had with Epstein was far different to what I had understood to be the position when I appointed him.
But as he tried to address the Mandelson crisis, Mr Ovenden, a longstanding member of his staff, was leaving Downing Street over revelations he had sent emails that used explicit sexual language about Ms Abbott.
A No 10 spokesperson said: “These messages are appalling and unacceptable. As the first black woman to be elected to parliament, Diane Abbott is a trailblazer who has faced horrendous abuse throughout her political career. These kinds of comments have no place in our politics.”
With Labour losing seats to Reform in three council by-elections last week, there was a feeling that the wheels are in danger of coming off.
Pollster Robert Hayward noted that postal voting means last week’s council by-elections would not have fully reflected the scandals which led to the resignation of Angela Rayner as deputy prime minister over her tax affairs and Lord Mandelson’s sacking.
He told The Independent: “Those two events will have a significant impact on the polls going forward. Last week’s results were bad – but Labour has not hit rock bottom yet.”
Meanwhile, Professor Sir John Curtice noted: “All three Reform gains were on around 30 per cent of the vote. That’s often enough to win in our fractured politics.”

Meanwhile, Mr Farage – with a 10-point poll lead for Reform over Labour – unveiled the first sitting Tory MP to defect to him, with Danny Kruger switching to his party.
But even with Kemi Badenoch’s leadership of the Tories in freefall, Labour MPs were more concerned about their own leader and whether he could survive. Some suggested Sir Keir could be gone, while others said he has until next May’s elections in English councils and the Scottish and Welsh parliaments to turn it around.
Labour Norwich South MP Clive Lewis warned on Friday that Sir Keir “doesn’t seem up to the job”, while fellow MP Graham Stringer said the prime minister is “supping in the last-chance saloon”.
There was speculation that Mr Stringer may step down to allow Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham to replace him so he could replace Sir Keir.