Tuesday 17 November 2026
by BILL HEANEY
Scottish Conservative Leader Russell Findlay has called for a tougher approach to welfare dependency following the publication of Alan Milburn’s review into youth unemployment.
The report exposes a system that spends £25 on benefit payments for young people for every £1 spent helping them into work, despite more than 7 in 10 young people not in employment, education or training, known as NEETs.
Findlay, pictured right, said this imbalance is indefensible and that the priority must be moving people off benefits and into employment, rather than endlessly expanding taxpayer-funded support.
He said businesses must be given the confidence to take on young workers through lower costs and fewer barriers, alongside a renewed focus on apprenticeships and colleges such as West College Clydebank.
With John Swinney’s Budget approaching, the SNP must show it is serious about tackling welfare dependency, reducing the burden on taxpayers and backing the businesses that create jobs.
Scottish Conservative leader, Russell Findlay MSP, said: “Labour has finally woken up to the failings of a welfare system that is too focused on paying people benefits rather than helping them find work.
“Labour has allowed welfare spending to spiral while making it harder for businesses to create jobs.
“This is the wrong approach. We need to get people off benefits and into employment, not keep expanding a system that traps people in dependency.
“The answer is to back employers by cutting business rates, invest in apprenticeships and give young people the skills they need to secure decent jobs. We should be reducing the costs facing businesses, not throwing more taxpayers’ money at subsidised schemes.
“John Swinney must take note ahead of his Budget. Scotland cannot afford another year of soaring welfare spending, punishing taxes and an SNP government that refuses to get to grips with the problem.”
The report argues that welfare spending is too focused on maintaining inactivity rather than getting young people into work. For every £25 spent on benefit income for young people, only £1 is spent on support to help them into employment. More than seven in ten young people who are NEET want a job or training. (From a Welfare State to a Working State, November 2026, link).
Young people who can work would be expected to engage with employment, training or education. Claimants would have to pursue a Participation Plan and not refuse reasonable opportunities without good cause. Persistent refusal to engage could ultimately result in losing the proposed Youth Allowance. (From a Welfare State to a Working State, November 2026, link).
This would replace the Universal Credit health top-up and remove the Work Capability Assessment for this age group, while combining financial support with guaranteed routes into work, education or training. (From a Welfare State to a Working State, November 2026, link).
Young people would be guaranteed a route into work, education or training. Options would include subsidised jobs, apprenticeships, further education, pre-apprenticeships and work placements. If someone remained NEET for 12 months despite engaging with support, the state would guarantee a six-month paid job where work was realistically possible. (From a Welfare State to a Working State, November 2026, link).
- Apprenticeships are identified as the report’s biggest education and skills priority. It proposes doubling youth apprenticeship completions, increasing annual under-25 starts to 270,000 and creating 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places. (From a Welfare State to a Working State, November 2026, link).
Top of page: Young West Dunbartonshire men who chose apprenticeships.