Major report urges government to crack down on benefits for under-25s and offer employers incentives to tackle youth unemployment crisis
The “great British promise” of hard work leading to a better life has been broken, the author of a government-commissioned report on the youth unemployment crisis has warned.
Alan Milburn said Britain must cut benefits and invest billions of pounds in job schemes, adding: “I’m part of a generation that has, by and large, done pretty well…
“Work hard, and you build a better life. That great British promise for this generation is being broken. Our job is to fix it.”
In a 267-page document, Mr Milburn set out measures to halve the number of Neets (people aged 16 to 24 not in employment, education or training) from 13.4% to around 6.8% by 2036.
But he said Britain should aim to reach a 5% NEET rate, which he dubbed “neet zero”.
Under the former cabinet minister’s plan, under-25s would stop being eligible for the disability benefit personal independence payment (PIP) and the health element of universal credit (UC), with a new “youth allowance” instead.
He also recommended giving employers up to £7,000 for hiring under-25s who have been a NEET for six months and lowering employer National Insurance over five years for workers aged 21 to 24.
Think tank warns young people with less severe disabilities to be impacted
The Institute for Fiscal Studies said the proposals would mean “many of those with less severe disabilities would be likely to see large income losses initially”, although this could be offset if they entered work.
The forecast £3.6 billion a year savings would be equivalent to 41% of projected spending on health-related benefits for young people in 2036–37, the think tank said.
Alan Milburn said his plan was a change from a “fiscal grab” with the idea “let’s cut some benefits” under Sir Keir Starmer, which ended in humiliation for the then prime minister.
Burnham challenged to back £5.8bn-a-year reforms to tackle youth unemployment
Andy Burnham and Chancellor John Healey have been challenged to spend billions to implement wholesale reforms to tackle youth unemployment or risk a “lost generation” of youngsters.
The Prime Minister said the report should be a “watershed moment,” but the Government did not immediately commit to implementing all the changes demanded by Alan Milburn, which would cost up to £5.8 billion annually.
Despite the plan to cut billions off the welfare bill and a projected extra £2.4 billion of tax revenue from people in work, the package would result in just £200 million of savings in 2036-37 because of the cost of youth support, tax breaks and bonuses for businesses hiring young workers.
Mr Milburn said there was a “clear political imperative” for Mr Burnham and the Chancellor to press ahead with the measures.
He said: “Prime Minister Burnham is a half-term prime minister and so he needs to get on with it. And I know that he wants to. So I’m very hopeful indeed.”
Cutting employers’ national insurance ‘right and necessary’, Labour MP says
Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden has faced pressure to say whether the Government will cut the “jobs tax”.
Alan Milburn, who has completed a review into youth unemployment, has called for a “five-year glide path to lower national insurance costs for workers aged 21 to 24 – starting in the retail and hospitality sectors which together provide 37 per cent of jobs for young people aged 16 to 24”.
The former cabinet minister said while he did not believe “an immediate across-the-board national insurance cut is the best use of several billion pounds of public money”, employers had warned him “higher payroll costs have made recruitment more difficult”.
The rate of employer national insurance rose from 13.8 per cent to 15 per cent in April 2025, and the threshold at which it is paid was cut from £9,100 to £5,000.
Employers do not pay National Insurance contributions for their workers aged under 21 unless their salary is above a £50,270 threshold.
Alan Milburn is now the most powerful man in government
John Healey and Andy Burnham are under pressure to tackle youth unemployment
Alan Milburn spoke powerfully on the prime minister’s behalf today. Nick Robinson, of the BBC, pointed out that his report on young people and work tells nine cabinet ministers what to do, and asked: “Have you looked Andy Burnham in the eye and said, ‘Are you going to do this?’”
Milburn said he had, and that he believed Burnham would do it. “It is something that is seared on his soul.”
Milburn has done a remarkable job of preaching about the “moral crisis” of youth unemployment, and he and Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, have mounted an exceptional sales pitch to the Labour Party for a solution that does actually mean, as Milburn admitted today, that “some people will be worse off – initially”.
Prioritise local youths for jobs, says Milburn as Burnham prepares for EU deal
Employers should prioritise local youths for jobs, Alan Milburn has said, as the Prime Minister prepares to sign a deal with Brussels which could open the doors to thousands of European under-30s working in Britain.
The former minister also sought to downplay the impact of the EU-UK youth mobility deal on his plans to reduce the number of British young people not in education, employment or training (NEETs).
Andy Burnham is expected to agree a youth mobility scheme at a summit in Brussels on Friday, which could see tens of thousands of young Europeans come to work temporarily in the UK each year, and vice versa.
Mr Milburn said British young people should be the priority for hiring, whatever the outcome of the EU deal, as he spoke at a press conference after launching his review of the NEETs crisis.
He told reporters: “My message to the country, not just to the politicians but to employers, is that young people who are in those disadvantaged communities, they’ve got to come first. They should be the priority.
“In some ways, what has happened in the youth labour market over the last 15 or 20 years is that there has become an overdependence on migrant labour. You can see that.
“Migration has fallen now, and that creates an opportunity. It creates an opportunity for employers to reorient back towards employing young people from their communities, and that’s what they should do, in my view.”
Milburn to chair the new Youth Opportunities Unit
Alan Milburn has been appointed the chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit.
The former Labour health secretary unveiled his major report, proposing widespread changes to tax, welfare and education in a bid to get 440,000 young people into work by 2036.
The new government unit will report directly to the prime minister and will deliver the cross-government response.

A “fuller” response to Alan Milburn’s review into youth unemployment will come in the new year, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden has said.
Mr McFadden replied: “He is right that it is wide-ranging, and that there are many, many recommendations in that. For that reason, we will of course have to consider it fully and produce a fuller response to it and to the Timms review in the new year.
Pat McFadden refuses to say if PIP cuts will fund new system
Pat McFadden said the new system will be a “better deal for young people”, as he declined to say whether PIP cuts will fund it.
Alan Milburn’s report proposes an “entirely new benefit system for young people”, with a so-called youth allowance replacing both the health element of universal credit (UC) and personal independence payment (PIP) for 16- to 24-year-olds.
Mr McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, did not say whether PIP would be cut in a response to Labour former shadow chancellor John McDonnell.
Mr McFadden said he “appreciates the concern”, adding: “We are putting forward this new settlement because we believe it is a better deal for young people.
“Let’s get the support to the young people so that they have the experience of earning, of making their way, and that’s what this settlement offers.”

He points to an example of a young NEET who has applied for 2,500 jobs – “not an uncommon experience”.
But, he says, “If you don’t play ball, there is a consequence.”A young person will not be able to decide to not engage with support under his proposals, and would face losing their new Youth Allowance – which replaces Universal Credit – as a last resort.
He said: “Primarily, I’m less worried about the taxpayer. I’m more worried about the life chances of the individual. So, of course, in the end, there has to be sanctions. But that’s sort of an end stage. It’s not the first stage”
Tories accuse Labour of ‘cherry picking’ from Milburn review
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately has accused the Government of “cherry picking” from the Milburn review, choosing to focus on spending over saving.
She said: “This report, to its credit, finds some savings – £3.6 billion of them – albeit in 10 years.
“But the Secretary of State’s statement made no mention of savings. Not a peep. Why not?
“Is he too worried he will suffer the same fate as the last welfare secretary, who tried to make savings only to lose her job?”
Ms Whately added: “This statement seems true to form: cherry-pick the big-spending ideas they like and quietly ignore the savings their welfare-loving backbenchers can’t stomach.
“Stick their fingers in their ears and decide the solution is more government, more taxes, more welfare and leave their lost generation to pay the price.”
Ms Whately also claimed the Milburn report “trashed” the Government’s economic policies and recommended the Conservatives’ plan to reform disability benefits.

Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen
Whately has accused Labour of focusing on spending over saving and “offering not a peep about PIP”.