Board’s special measures an attempt to eradicate ‘catastrophic failings’

Former Health Minister Nicola Sturgeon and the £840 million super hospital.

By Bill Heaney

Recent events have shown that the SNP is incapable of running the health service at any level of government – national, regional or even local.

Special measures imposed on NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde by the Scottish government have been escalated amid ongoing concern over its performance.

The conflating of the regional board’s responsibilities with those of local authorities has been an unmitigated disaster.

Health and Social Care Partnerships simply haven’t worked and we have seen delegates attending meetings of this committee who looked entirely out of their depth.

The single member of the public who turned up for one meeting in Dumbarton said he could not make head nor tail of what was going on.

And that the Council communications department would not release to him any details about the background of the unelected chairperson, Allan Macleod, who confusingly switched roles with the SNP’s Cllr Marie McNair.  She moved between being chairperson and vice-chairperson.

Health and Social Care partnership players – Unelected Allan Macleod, Chief Executive Joyce White, Council leader Jonathan McColl and Cllr Marie McNair, Vice chairperson. McColl is also a member of the Health Board.

Council leader Jonathan McColl and Chief Executive Joyce White, without any democratic mandate, told the £500,000 Communications Department not to comment.

The board (was it the HSC Partnership or both?) came under fire for removing Dr David Neilson, one of the most popular GPs at Dumbarton Health Centre and arrogantly refused to present a petition to allow him to stay on.

It didn’t matter that about 1,200 of Dr Neilson’s patients signed that petition, it was made clear the Board would not be looking at it.

There is a lacuna of a democratic deficit in the organisation and administration of public services in West Dunbartonshire.

The health board has faced criticism over its infection control procedures after the deaths of two children at the city’s largest hospital complex.

It was partly placed in Stage 4 special measures in November.

Struggling to cope, SNP Government Health Secretary Jeane Freeman has now extended these measures to cover the entire health board.

Ms Freeman and the health board both apologised in November to the parents of two young patients who died in 2017 in the Royal Hospital for Children, which is part of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital (QEUH) campus.

  • The five-step process to keep Scotland’s NHS boards in line
  • Mother of hospital death boy: ‘I’ve been ignored’
  • Health secretary issues apology over child deaths

A five-stage scale is used in Scotland to show the level of oversight for stricken health boards, with a stage four ranking given to a board where there are “significant risks to delivery, quality, financial performance or safety” with “senior level external support required”.

Ms Freeman said the status will concentrate on scheduled care, unscheduled care, primary care out-of-hours, finance and culture and leadership.

The statistics for nearly every health service in West Dunbartonshire and South Argyll – that includes Helensburgh – are pathetic.

The Out of Hours Service at Vale of Leven Hospital, which is run by GPs is hardly ever open because of a shortage of GPs.

Ms Freeman has previously announced specific support for infection prevention and control, communications and engagement after saying there were “ongoing issues” at the hospitals.

Health secretary Jeane Freeman previously said there were ongoing issues with infection control at the hospitals. And she was questioned (above) about the state of arrairs at the Vale of Leven Hospital.

Calum Campbell, chief executive of NHS Lanarkshire, has been appointed as a “turnaround director” at NHSGGC to provide an “increased level of scrutiny and intervention”, and will report to the Scottish government on the progress that has been made.

Ms Freeman said: “All of us, rightly, have high expectations of our NHS and I’m focused on improving performance and delivery across the system in order to provide the best care possible for the people of Scotland.

“In order to provide additional direction and support to NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde I have taken the decision to escalate the board as a whole to stage 4 of the Performance Escalation Framework.”

Jane Grant, Chief Executive, and John Brown, Chief Executive, who have been in charge during the time of “catastrophic failings” at the super hospital.

Three-year-old Mason Djemat, who was being treated for a rare genetic disease at the Royal Hospital for Children, died on 9 August 2017.

Milly Main, 10, died at the same hospital three weeks later while recovering from leukaemia treatment.

Both children were patients on a ward affected by water contamination, with their deaths emerging after Labour MSP Anas Sarwar was contacted by a whistleblower.

  • Timeline: The trials of Scotland’s super hospital

Mr Sarwar, who has previously exposed problems at the QEUH, said: “This is a step in the right direction, and it is encouraging that Jeane Freeman has recognised the scale of the crisis at NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.

“But the health board itself remains in complete denial of its catastrophic failings.

“It simply isn’t tenable for those in charge to remain in post. They have lost the trust of patients, families and the public.”

Meanwhile, the health secretary also announced additional steps to support NHS Highland and NHS Orkney.


  1. Personally, I think people should start thinking about the fantastic good that the NHS does.

    And good it does do, and many of us are more than thankful for the support provided by hard working dedicated NHS personnel. Free at the point of service do we want an American system where if you cannot pay you don’t get. or do we get a system hollowed out by privatisation as its headed in England.

    It’s a cheap shot that cat calls the NHS for political advantage. But there you are, the SNP cannot run an NHS, cannot build enough social houses for folks to grow old in, cannot educate our children, cannot maintain our roads, support hundreds of jobs in keeping afloat a busted wreck of a shipyard on the Clyde. The cat calls just go on and on and on.

    Well here’s the deal Lets introduce a fee for going to the doctor as our local Labour MSP suggested some years back. Keep the wasters away from the doc’s. Or what about the Labour policy of privatising cleaning services in hospitals when they were in power. That was a rip roaring success want it and people grieve today for their lost ones. But who was it that brought the privatised cleaning back into public service?

    Or what about education. Maybe what we need is to introduce tuition fees as labour have previously proposed. Well Tony Blair was privately educated and our local MSP was I believe a huge New Labour fan and privately educated, so maybe a wee bit of New Labour privatisation in education required.

    Or what of Fergusson’s shipyard. After going bust the Scottish Government stepped in and pulled forward contracts for new ferries so that the yard could keep going with around 400 jobs saved. Now years late with it being suggested in some quarters that the building quality is so bad that the ships should be scrapped and start again. So much for keeping the yard going. Maybe like the rest of Clyde shipbuilding now gone, the bad SNP should have allowed market forces to let them go down the pan.

    Or what of the Labour and Tory embargo on social house building to drive up house prices. A wizard idea to create a property price asset bubble that banks could lend on. Make them expensive until Big Broon of the prudence fame nearly brought the house down. At least under the SNP we are now building social houses again as can be seen at Dumbarton Harbour, the new houses in Castle Hill and Bruce Hill. The new social houses in the Vale and the new social houses in Bellsmyre to name but a few new schemes. Crikey editor, this is an SNP baad policy. We should not, and I mean not be building social houses – and if you cant buy then you should be privately renting. That’s after all what Tony Blair did buying multiple properties in London.

    Well pray say commentators and readers all, when do we want to start the new privatisation of the NHS and or the policy of letting engineering companies go bankrupt. Fergusons , Prestwick Airport, why were they saved. Shoulder to shoulder with the Tories it’s definitely SNP baad – but maybe, just maybe that’s why the people gave the SNP 48 out of 59 MPs last month’s General Election with Labour getting only one sole MP>.

    The court of public opinion is I think crystal clear!


Leave a Reply to willie Cancel reply