Alex Salmond and Fist Minister Nicola Sturgeon.

By Bryan Stuart in the Scottish Review

There is a new political landscape in the UK following the General Election. The island of Ireland is moving towards much closer integration and Scotland is at a tipping point between two unions.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon is still overshadowed by the achievements of her predecessor, Alex Salmond, and appears to be promoting a wholly impractical indyref2 simply to divert attention from her strategic dithering.

As an economist, Mr Salmond did not foresee currency being a major issue with independence, given the nature of the future relationship he promoted in 2014 was essentially one of confederation within a UK in the EU. The flat refusal of the UK Government to countenance continuing to share sterling by arrangement will echo down the pages of history as the key break point if Scotland again becomes independent.

The Tories (formerly known as the Conservative and Unionist Party) are hurtling lemming-like towards the abyss, with a leadership that apes Trump’s irrationality but lacks his originality. Boris Johnson could still deliver a soft Brexit that minimised economic damage to the UK as a whole by adopting the same arrangements being put in place for Northern Ireland UK-wide, but all the indications are that he would rather have a no deal one.

The SNP was foolish to support a December election, and should not have been influenced by the catastrophic Liberal Democratic leadership of Jo Swinson. Inevitably, Labour’s Jeremy Corbyn was manoeuvred into falling in behind that too. England’s century of substantive social democratic parliamentary representation toppled at one blow. Labour has now been absorbed by the SNP in Scotland, just as Nigel Farage’s Brexit Party has become part of the Tories.

Ms Sturgeon’s performance on public platforms was head and shoulders above the other party leaders during the election. However, there is a policy vacuum when it comes to articulating meaningful economic development proposals sufficiently to convince another 15-20% of Scots who currently remain unpersuaded on Scottish independence. She needs to stop seeking to manage the aspirations of the SNP’s membership and focus on opening up real internal debate and consequent policy formulation.

Bryan Stuart


  1. In Scotland the SNP got 48 seats in Scotland whilst Labour got one.

    And in England the Tories wiped the floor with Labour giving them a huge majority over Labour. Seems to me that Labour let the side down. Found wanting the voters do just not trust them.

    But we need to move things on. The democratic deficit whereby Scotland repeatedly gets a government it doesn’t vote for is outrageous. We didn’t vote for Johnson and Rees Mogg. Nor Thatcher for that matter either. Nor did we vote to be dragged out of Europe.

    Time we changed things and secured our independence. And make no mistake the SNP membership, and the much wider audience of the Scottish electorate beyond that is up for that change.

  2. I really think they need to change the manager, Willie. And that woman who keeps running on with the sponge and the medical bag. She’s toast, even if it is Burns’ Day tomorrow and she’s called Jeane. She may even come frae Mauchline. Btw, Rabbie was a Freeman o’ the Royal Burgh of Dumbarton. Hope he’s no’ a relative.

Leave a Reply to willie Cancel reply