UK results: Conservatives win majority

After 650 of 650 seats declared
UK results
Party Conservative Labour Scottish National Party Liberal Democrat Democratic Unionist Party Others
Seats 365 203 48 11 8 15
Change +47 -59 +13 -1 -2 +2
  • 15 December 2019

Nicola Sturgeon told the BBC’s Andrew Marr Show that Scotland ‘cannot be imprisoned’ in UK

Scotland “cannot be imprisoned in the union against its will” by the UK government, Nicola Sturgeon has said.

The Scottish first minister says the SNP’s success in the general election gives her a mandate to hold a new referendum on independence.

However, UK ministers are opposed to such a move with Michael Gove saying the vote in 2014 should be “respected”.

Ms Sturgeon told the BBC that if the UK was to continue as a union, “it can only be by consent”.

She told The Andrew Marr Show that the UK government would be “completely wrong” to think saying no to a referendum would be the end of the matter, adding: “It’s a fundamental point of democracy – you can’t hold Scotland in the union against its will.”

However Mr Gove told the Sophy Ridge programme on Sky that “we were told in 2014 that that would be a choice for a generation – we are not going to have an independence referendum in Scotland”.

  • PM Johnson ‘remains opposed’ to holding indyref2
  • Sturgeon: PM has ‘no right’ to block indyref2
  • Live updates: Latest reaction to Tory win

The SNP won a landslide of Scottish seats in the snap general election, making gains from the Conservatives and Labour and unseating Lib Dem leader Jo Swinson.

However UK-wide the Conservatives won a comfortable majority, returning Boris Johnson to Downing Street and setting up a constitutional stand-off over Scotland’s future.

The Scottish government wants a referendum deal with UK ministers similar to that which underpinned the 2014 vote, to ensure that the outcome is legal and legitimate – but are facing opposition from the UK government.

Ms Sturgeon said it was “fundamentally not democratic” for Mr Johnson to rule out a referendum when his party had been “defeated comprehensively” in Scotland – losing seven of its 13 seats while standing on a platform of opposition to independence.

Sturgeon Ducherty Hughes and O'Hara of SNP

Nicola Sturgeon was speaking on the BBC’s Andrew Marr Show.

The SNP leader said: “I said this to him on Friday night on the telephone – if he thinks saying no is the end of the matter then he’s going to find himself completely and utterly wrong.

“It’s a fundamental point of democracy – you can’t hold Scotland in the union against its will. You can’t lock us in a cupboard and turn the key and hope everything goes away.

“If the UK is to continue it can only be by consent. If Boris Johnson is confident in the case for the union he should be confident enough to make that case and allow people to decide.

“Scotland cannot be imprisoned within the United Kingdom against its will. These are just basic statements of democracy.”

‘Contempt for democracy’

Ms Sturgeon added: “The risk for the Conservatives here is the more they try to block the will of the Scottish people, the more utter contempt they show for Scottish democracy, the more they will increase support for Scottish independence – which in a sense is them doing my job for me.

“The momentum and the mandate is on the side of those of us who think Scotland should be independent, but also on the side of those who want Scotland to be able to chose its own future.”

Boris at Base 1

Mr Johnson, pictured here during a visit to the Clyde Naval Base,  returned to Downing Street on Friday after the Conservatives won a big majority in the election

Mr Johnson spoke to Ms Sturgeon on the phone after being returned to government, and told her that he “remains opposed” to a second independence vote.

A Downing Street spokesman said the prime minster was “standing with the majority of people in Scotland who do not want to return to division and uncertainty”.

This was echoed on Sunday morning by Mr Gove, the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster, who said the result of the previous referendum in 2014 should hold for “a generation”.

He said: “In this general election we have just seen what happens when politicians try to overturn a referendum result, and in the same way we should respect the referendum result in 2014 in Scotland.

“Scotland is stronger in the United Kingdom. You can be proudly Scottish and proudly British together.

“The best of this country are British institutions like the NHS and the BBC, and therefore we should be proud of what we have achieved together and confident that the UK is a strong partnership that works in the interests of all.”


After 59 of 59 seats

  • Scottish National Party
    ,+13seats compared to 2017
  • Conservative
    ,-7seats compared to 2017
  • Liberal Democrat
    ,+0seats compared to 2017
  • Labour
    ,-6seats compared to 2017

Labour went into the election opposing independence in principle, but open to the idea of backing a referendum should pro-independence parties win the majority of seats in the 2021 Holyrood election.

The party lost all but one of its Scottish seats, shedding votes in every constituency, and former MP Paul Sweeney said it was important for Labour to “reflect” on the constitutional position.

He told the BBC’s Sunday Politics Scotland programme: “The way the British state is currently constructed is not sustainable. I think we need to develop a clear policy which is in the form of an ultimatum to the UK government.

“You have to say to the British government that unless you recognise that the Scottish body politic at large is not willing to accept the current status quo, unless you recognise that there has to be a major engagement with the Scottish body politic to reform the British state and recognise the difference of opinion in Scotland, then the UK is unsustainable.

“A more federal relationship is something that urgently needs to happen, and I think we need to be galvanised to present an argument that that needs to happen.”


  1. Reblogged this on The Most Revolutionary Act and commented:
    Ms Sturgeon said it was “fundamentally not democratic” for Mr Johnson to rule out a referendum when his party had been “defeated comprehensively” in Scotland – losing seven of its 13 seats while standing on a platform of opposition to independence.

Leave a Reply